trade-ideas

Nvidia Is Acting Like a Value Trap

We need price action to confirm the market has been wrong about valuation, and Nvidia isn’t providing it. Amazon action is promising.

James "Rev Shark" DePorre·Nov 18, 2026, 11:00 AM EST

You've reached your free article limit

You've read 0 of 1 free Pro articles.

Already registered or a Pro member? Log in
Nvidia Is Acting Like a Value Trap

Minor opening strength was quickly sold Wednesday morning. Too many traders were hopeful that Nvidia (NVDA) would be a turning point for the market, and when stronger momentum failed to develop, they quickly ran for the exits.

Breadth is running about even, and the Magnificent Seven names are generally holding up relatively well. However, this is a nervous market, and minor strength is being used as an opportunity to reduce risk.

Great Earnings Can Be Deceiving

Nvidia reported great earnings, raised its forecast for next year and opened higher this morning. It quickly went negative.

Great earnings and guidance can be deceiving. Nvidia is telling us that its business will grow 75% next year. If investors believed that, they wouldn’t be running away from a stock that trades at around 10 times next year’s estimated earnings. The price action says they don’t believe it.

Sellers Were Waiting

In addition, many folks were looking for an opportunity to sell into any strength in Nvidia. They didn’t care about valuation. They just wanted the report to produce some strength so they could flip some shares. Longer-term holders who have watched the stock lose a third of its value also wanted a better exit, and a pop on good news is the best one they are likely to get for a while.

On the other side are buyers attracted by the valuation. They don’t seem to have a lot of conviction, and they are being overwhelmed. A buyer who is there because the stock is cheap tends to wait for it to get cheaper. A seller who wants out doesn’t wait.

Valuation Is Not Support

One of the biggest mistakes traders have made recently, especially in the chip sector, is thinking that valuation would provide support. I wrote about this two weeks ago when the chip stocks were routed. The low price-to-earnings ratios fooled a lot of people into thinking the downside was limited.

Price action overwhelms valuation arguments in the short term. Quite often it is the estimates that eventually come down, and the stock that looked cheap turns out to have been expensive all along. Chip stocks have a long history of looking their cheapest right before earnings peak, because the market sees the slowdown coming before the analysts put it in their numbers.

That is what a value trap is. It is a stock that looks cheap, draws in buyers on the way down and keeps going lower. Nvidia is acting like one right now.

I’m not saying Nvidia’s estimates are wrong. I don’t know, and nobody else does either. There is an SEC investigation, the company is financing its own customers and big customers are building their own chips. What I do know is that the market is refusing to pay up for those estimates, and I’m not going to argue with it.

Game Plan

I came into the day looking to put more capital to work, but the failed open changed that. I’m doing nothing right now. I still have my small position in Nvidia, and I’m not adding to it or starting anything new.

No one is rushing to buy values like Nvidia right now, and they especially aren’t interested in buying small-cap value when the market action is this poor. There are many stocks I think are mispriced, but it doesn’t matter what I think until buyers show up. I’ll keep tracking them and build a shopping list, but I am not going to act on it until there is better price action.

My position in Amazon (AMZN) is acting well, and I’m happy with that. It briefly broke its 50-day simple moving average on Tuesday and is gaining some momentum this morning. I have a pretty good-sized position there now and may increase it further.

The good news about this poor market is that this terrible action is part of the process that gets us to better chart formations. It takes time, and you have to avoid the temptation to buy stocks because you hope the market is mispricing them. You need price action to confirm that the market has been wrong.

At the time of publication, Rev Shark was long NVDA and AMZN.