market-commentary

Everyone Owned the Same AI Stocks, and Now It’s a Stock Picker’s Market

Crowded positions produced violent swings. Nvidia’s report and the Anthropic IPO will help show which AI stocks outperform.

James "Rev Shark" DePorre·Nov 16, 2026, 7:26 AM EST

You've reached your free article limit

You've read 0 of 1 free Pro articles.

Already registered or a Pro member? Log in
Everyone Owned the Same AI Stocks, and Now It’s a Stock Picker’s Market

We have a weak open setting up Monday morning, and the chip stocks are leading to the downside again. The Invesco QQQ Trust (QQQ) is down about 1%, the VanEck Semiconductor ETF (SMH) is down more than 3% and Nvidia (NVDA) is slipping again.

There isn’t a major new headline causing the selling. Chips were weak on Friday, the weakness spread to Asia overnight, and now it is coming back around to us ahead of a week that includes Nvidia’s earnings on Tuesday and the Anthropic IPO.

Everyone Owned the Same Stocks

The violent swings of the past month are understandable when you look at how crowded the AI trade had become. According to Morgan Stanley, AI hardware stocks made up roughly 40% of its hedge fund clients’ portfolios this summer. Goldman Sachs called it “One Big Trade” and found that almost 85% of the excess returns at stock-picking hedge funds in the first half of the year came from AI positions.

When everyone owns the same stocks, there is nobody left to buy when they decide to sell. Nvidia lost more than $570 billion in market value last week, the largest weekly decline for any company on record.

Funds that are forced to cut positions don’t sell in an orderly way. They sell in sudden dumps, and that is why we keep seeing huge down days followed by sharp one-day rallies that go nowhere. Those rallies are about positioning, and they will keep failing until the forced selling is finished. The sign that it is ending will be bad news that no longer pushes these stocks to new lows.

Individual investors are on the other side. Last Tuesday was their second-biggest day of Nvidia buying on record, even as the stock sank. I wrote last week that familiarity makes people comfortable buying broken stocks, and they are buying what the hedge funds are selling.

A Different Kind of AI Trade

For three years, nearly everything tied to AI went up, and investors didn’t have to make hard choices. That era is over. AI isn’t going away, but from here the winners and losers are going to separate, and that makes it a stock picker’s market.

All of OpenAI’s planned data-center capacity that hasn’t broken ground is in states where the new governor backs a pause on construction, according to The Wall Street Journal. Amazon (AMZN) has less than half of its planned capacity in those states and more projects already under construction than anyone else. SpaceX (SPCX) has moved faster than anyone by building its own power plants, but two of its projects now have permits tied up, and Elon Musk’s goals for next year look harder to reach.

The same shakeout is happening with financing. The companies that depended on Nvidia’s money are being separated from the ones that can fund themselves.

I view this as a positive for traders in the longer run. A market where everything moves together on one theme doesn’t reward stock picking. A market that separates the strong from the weak does. It takes a while to get there, and the process is painful.

What I’m Watching This Week

Nvidia reports earnings after the close Tuesday. The quarter isn’t the issue, because it ended before any of the drama started. I want to hear whether interim CEO Colette Kress stands by her earlier forecast of about 70% revenue growth next year, and what she says about the financing Nvidia provides to its customers. That forecast is the reason the stock looks cheap. If she backs away from it, the estimates come down and the stock won’t look as cheap, but it would take a big cut before valuation becomes a major concern.

Anthropic is expected to price its IPO Wednesday and start trading later in the week. It is raising as much as $64 billion, and how the market absorbs that much stock will tell us a lot about the appetite for AI. Anthropic is different from the recent SpaceX IPO in that it doesn’t appear to have the same level of shares scheduled to be unlocked in the future. Many of the institutional buyers of SpaceX waited for the unlocks to buy rather than chase the IPO.

The bond market still hangs over everything. The 10-year Treasury yield is above 5%, Fed officials are speaking all week, and the minutes of the October meeting come out on Wednesday.

Game Plan

My approach hasn’t changed. I’m holding a high level of cash and waiting for charts to develop. A week with this many catalysts is likely to produce big swings in both directions, and I’d rather react to them than try to guess the outcome. I want to build some bigger positions and put some cash to work, but I need better market conditions before I do so.

I still have a small position in Nvidia, and I’ll hold it through the earnings report. I’m using it as a tracking position to keep me focused on finding another good entry for a fast, aggressive trade. My stop is still $150.

At the time of publication, Rev Shark was long NVDA, AMZN and SPCX.