The Trading Secret Nobody Wants to Hear

If you have been around the market for any length of time, you have seen the pitch. Use this indicator. Follow this formula. Buy the one stock that is about to make you rich.

Sometimes famous names like Jesse Livermore, Stanley Druckenmiller, or Warren Buffett get dragged into it, but the message is always the same: It’s easy once you know the secret, and the secret can be yours for a monthly fee.

I’ve been doing this for a long time, and I can save you the subscription cost. The secret to successful trading is that there is no secret. A good service like TheStreetPro can give you ideas and show you a process. But it can’t do the work for you.

You Can’t Buy It

In recent weeks, I’ve been writing about discipline: setting and respecting stops, getting back on track when the market punishes you, and building armor against your own worst impulses. Every one of those columns comes back to the same uncomfortable truth: Success in the market is a product of hard work and persistence, and even the best traders in the world go through stretches when they can’t do anything right.

That isn’t what people want to hear. They want a shortcut and a sure thing, and an entire industry is happy to sell it to them. The problem is that neither a shortcut nor a sure thing exists. If a simple formula reliably produced big profits, everyone would use it, and once everyone used it, it would stop working.

The Noise Is Louder Than Ever

In the last decade or so, the search for the secret has moved to social media, and it has never been noisier or more obnoxious. Every day, thousands of people post their winning trades, their can’t-miss setups, and their predictions for where the market is headed.

Kristjan Kullamägi, the momentum trader I quoted two weeks ago, put it bluntly: “Most people on Twitter are broke. There’s no reason to listen to them. Follow the price action.”

Martin Luk, another successful trader with a big following, deleted his social media apps for months. “Most people talking out there are not consistently profitable, just looking for attention or someone who agrees with them,” he said.

They are both right. The people who post the most are rarely the ones making the most. You see the winning screenshots. You never see the accounts that quietly blew up. Listening to that noise doesn’t bring you closer to the secret. It makes you wonder if you are missing something, and it pulls you away from your own process.

The Closest Thing to a Secret

If there is anything close to a secret, George Soros summed it up years ago: “I’m not better than the next trader, just quicker at admitting my mistakes and moving on to the next opportunity.”

That is about as close as we will ever get. Admit your mistakes quickly, cut your losses and move on to the next trade. You will make mistakes constantly, but if you deal with them fast, you will be in position to take advantage of the opportunities that do work. One sure sign that you are becoming a professional is when you take losing trades in stride and consider them a normal part of the process.

Beyond that, there are three things you need. First, you need a style or approach that makes sense to you, so you can embrace it and stick with it. Second, you need a steady supply of good ideas to apply it to. Third, you need a methodology for managing positions once you own them.

Then you need to work at it day after day for years. The traders who build great fortunes don’t put it all on red and spin the wheel. They dig for new ideas every day and work hard at managing them. In real estate, the three most important things are location, location, location. The trading version of that mantra is repetition, repetition, repetition.

It’s You Versus You

The market is a competitive sport, but the competition isn’t with the other traders. It’s with yourself. Luk put it this way: “Trading is only a game, like a solo player game. It’s only you versus you.” I wrote the same thing more than a decade ago. There is no secret formula to the market. It is all in your head.

Your opponent is the impulse to skip the stop, the urge to chase a stock because everyone is talking about it, and the temptation to freeze when the losses pile up. No indicator or subscription can fight that battle for you. The only thing that works is a process you trust and the discipline to keep applying it, especially when it is uncomfortable.

Most people are unwilling or unable to apply discipline, patience, and persistence day after day over a long period of time. If you are one of the few who can, you are going to have different results than the many who can’t.

Grit, Not Genius

In the short term, there may be no connection at all between your effort and your results. You can do everything right and still lose money for weeks. That is when most people quit or go looking for a new secret, and that is when you need to keep pushing. Hard work in the market isn’t just putting in hours. It is continually learning, adapting, and questioning why you are doing what you are doing.

The good news is that few businesses offer the steady supply of opportunities that trading does. The market will keep giving you chances for as long as you are willing to show up and work at them.

So here is the secret, for free. Ignore the noise. Follow the price action. Be objective, cut your losses, and stick to your process. Trade methodically, day after day, for years on end.

It isn’t easy. However, if it were easy, it wouldn’t have the potential to make you rich.

More Investing and Trading From Rev Shark:

At the time of publication, Rev Shark had no positions in any securities mentioned.