market-commentary

Not a Whiff of Panic, Even as Breadth Starts to Roll Over

There are still places for investors to hide, but that could be changing.

Helene Meisler·Nov 17, 2026, 6:00 AM EST

You've reached your free article limit

You've read 0 of 1 free Pro articles.

Already registered or a Pro member? Log in
Not a Whiff of Panic, Even as Breadth Starts to Roll Over

There was no panic on Monday. Because there were still places to hide. And all those folks who, a few short weeks ago, screamed that we must hate markets where the Utes, staples, and drugs lead seemed to be perfectly fine with those groups now.  I heard none of that on Monday. Nope, now it was good that we had these groups that act well. This is how sentiment shifts from ‘only growth stocks are good for the market to aw heck, Costco is fine at 50 times earnings because their earnings are so reliable’.

But while these folks were changing their tune, there is a lot of rolling over elsewhere, and I don’t just mean growth/tech. The McClellan Summation Index has rolled over. It will now need a net differential of +1200 advancers minus decliners to halt the decline and more to turn it back up. This is the first time it has rolled over since it turned up in early October. Mark this as Exhibit A on why I think the ‘others’ are due for a rollover.

And while everyone was changing their tune about the staples and the utes, no one seemed to notice that breadth made a lower low. So much for that broadening-out trade. This is Exhibit B.

While everyone was suddenly okay with staples, utes and drugs rallying (or at least not going down), the number of stocks making new lows on the NYSE pushed up yet again. This is now the highest reading since late September. As a reminder, RSP, the equal-weight S&P (the ‘others’), is still five percent higher than it was back in late September. Mark this down as Exhibit C.

Regarding the RSP, back in early August everyone was raving about the broadening out, and they cited the RSP breaking out (over the blue line). At the time I scoffed, saying ‘no’ to the ‘others’. Well, just a week or so ago I heard chatter about the RSP at a new high and how it was breaking out (green line). It has since come back under rather handily. Call this Exhibit D as to why I am no longer bullish on the ‘others’.

Let’s talk about the Staples now, using XLP, the chart everyone seems to love, or at least be at peace with now. I liked the Staples back in September mostly because everyone hated them and the chart refused to break down. But up here, I am not a fan. The chart hasn’t done anything wrong yet. But a giant pullback is needed. A move back to the blue line, or somewhere near there, would be beneficial in my view. And might even get the hidey holes to vanish.

I would love to see a market with nowhere to run or hide. I would love to see some panic. I see the seeds of folks getting bearish, but I do not see the extremes I think we need. Of course, with the major indexes now red for three straight days, we’ll probably rally on Tuesday just to avoid getting any sort of panic.