Office Hours: Frustration, Footing and a Pivotal Week Ahead
Answering your latest Office Hours questions and why we’re staying patient ahead of Nvidia and the retail parade.
You've reached your free article limit
You've read 0 of 1 free Pro articles.
With the market taking another drubbing, Chris Versace uses this week’s Office Hours to address subscriber frustration head on and explain why we’re staying patient and closely watching key market technical indicators.
The next few days are packed: Nvidia (NVDA) earnings Tuesday night, reports from Walmart (WMT), Home Depot (HD), Lowe’s (LOW), Target (TGT) and TJX (TJX), and the upcoming Trump-Xi-Putin meeting.
Barring a major market flush, any moves we make this week are likely to be small. Chris also takes questions on TJX, Nvidia’s leadership transition, the Anthropic IPO and what it means for SpaceX (SPCX), Google (GOOGL), gold, rotating beyond tech and other #OfficeHours questions.
Transcript
Hi everybody, Chris Versace here. It’s Monday afternoon, and as you’ve probably noticed, we’ve seen another drubbing in the market, with continued questions on a number of different fronts. As I laid out in my comments to you earlier today, there are a number of things at play, not just over the last several weeks but in the coming several days as well. What the market is trying to grapple with is where the key support levels are and whether they will hold. We talked with you this afternoon about why we’re watching the 50-day moving average on the weekly chart of the Nasdaq Composite, as well as some other levels we’re looking at on the S&P 500.
I understand that folks are frustrated, and that’s something I want to address here and now. If you look back over the last several weeks, call it October and into November, it’s been a very challenging time for the market. There hasn’t been that “whoosh” moment people look forward to, a clearing out. Instead, it’s been one thing after another that calls into question whether the market has found its footing.
Just coming into November, for example, there was the blue wave, raising all sorts of questions about AI and the data center build-out. There were the continued capital-raising efforts by the hyperscalers and others to shore up funding for capital spending and capacity additions. Last week’s inflation numbers had the CPI coming in arguably warmer than expected, and the PPI arguably a little better, but still up big. The market now expects the Fed will have to do more than it previously thought. Then there are the issues with Jensen Huang: good, bad or indifferent. They’re obviously bad from a headline perspective, but in my view, indifferent when it comes to NVIDIA’s competitive position. That’s given its roadmap and the fact that Jensen, while a heavily spotlighted individual, is still just one person inside a company with a rather deep bench, particularly on the technical side.
On top of all that, we have this latest round of chip export news, which I think is going to raise more questions, as I pointed out in today’s alert. And the mood, honestly, is just extremely foul.
I know a lot of folks feel like we should be doing something. Looking over at the Portfolio forum, I think Beachman asked who has the cojones to step up and do something. I understand that, I really do. People want to put capital to work, and they don’t want to miss the bottom. But the question, and I think Helene Meisler has done a very good job raising it, is whether the market has found its footing. Has the bottom been put in? Remember, too, that if we do put in a bottom, it’s likely to be tested. Emotions are running high, and I’d add in the rampant use of social media and clickbait headlines, so I think we need to be extra careful as we navigate the coming couple of days.
Could the market find its footing? Certainly, it’s possible. Is it very difficult to bottom-tick the market? Yes, it is. Remember, our goal isn’t so much focused on the next day or the next week. We want to make sure we’re rightly positioned for the coming 12 to 18 months, as I always talk about with you.
Having said that, are we looking at some names outside of our arguably tech-heavy focus? Yes, we are. Look at some of the names we’ve brought into the Bullpen of late. Even though we pulled the trigger on SpaceX for a very particular reason, you’ll see other names outside the tech landscape, and we’re going to continue to evaluate names outside that sphere. However, we’ll stay focused on companies that are well positioned and poised to deliver multi-year EPS growth at a superior clip. We’ll also look for the other attributes that help us identify what we call well-positioned companies, particularly ones benefiting from structural change.
Will we be making any moves this week? I can’t tell you that. As I wrote in one of today’s alerts, barring a major flush in the market that resets things, we’re still going to want to see the market test that footing. So anything we do is likely to be small, particularly given the series of events over the next couple of days.
We have NVIDIA earnings after the close Tuesday night. I was talking with Bob Lang today, and the question was whether they’ll amend their guidance. I said that with an interim CEO, I’d be very surprised to see any change to what’s already been said publicly. I think that’s more the job of the permanent CEO, but we’ll see. The way I think about it, though, the last time the company reported, it said it was 70% to 80% booked into 2027. Step that up a couple of months, and odds are it’s even more booked now. Could we hear that it’s booked into 2028? Certainly possible, and I think that would help shock people into realizing the company’s competitive position.
We also have a swath of retailers reporting. If you’re parsing the data like I am, consumers in aggregate are still contending with higher inflation. We continue to like Costco for that. We also continue to like TJX. Even though it’s been beaten up a bit, we still see it as rather well positioned for what we like to call the cash-strapped consumer. But we’re also seeing other data that says higher-end consumers are poised to spend, while lower-end and lower-middle-tier consumers are going to be spending less this holiday shopping season.
That’s some of the clarity we want to get from the retailers reporting, and it’s the who’s who: Walmart, Home Depot, Lowe’s, Target and TJX. I’d expect a lot of sobering commentary about the holiday shopping season, including whether consumers are trading down and moving to private-label brands, along with some other metrics. What we often hear companies talk about is basket size and frequency of visits. When times are tough, people try to stretch their dollars or conserve what they’re spending, so you tend to see smaller baskets and more frequent visits. We’ll be listening for all of that.
We also have the upcoming gathering between Putin, Xi and Trump, which I’m sure will be interesting. As I say that, I’m also seeing a headline today that a third U.S. aircraft carrier has arrived in the Middle East as Trump keeps his options open. Oil is falling and gas is falling, so we’ll see what happens on that front. Keep in mind this move is happening right before Trump meets with Putin and Xi, so we’ll have to pay extra-close attention to it. My suspicion is this is more of a negotiating tactic, but we’ll see.
On the meeting, particularly between Trump and Xi, it’ll be interesting to follow the comments about AI chips and whether there’s some resolution. My guess is they’re going to try to use that as a bargaining chip for other things. We’ll have to follow the details. But at least in the short term, the market is going to be focused on that geographic area in Asia, which accounts for about 25% of all global chip exports, and I think that explains some of the move we’re seeing today.
So we’re going to take it day by day and expect it to be volatile. We’re down today; we could be up tomorrow, depending on what develops in the headlines and what the market latches onto. While that happens, we’ll keep focusing on finding quality companies with superior growth prospects that we want to be long-term holders in. There are names inside the existing Portfolio that certainly land in that camp, and we’ve talked about our shopping list.
There are also a couple of names on the outside. Toast is a great example. We’ve talked about Toast quite a bit over the last several days, and we even shared our brand-new tear sheet for it, as well as the ones for IFF and a couple of others. We’re keeping a close eye on Toast. We like the recurring revenue stream and the share of every transaction that’s swiped. With oil and gas prices falling, we think consumers might be feeling a little more optimistic than they have been of late. That would bode well for dining-out dollars, which would be positive for Toast. So we’re taking a hard look at it, but again, we want the market to find its footing, or at least appear to, before we do anything on that front.
Office Hours Q&A
With that, I want to switch over to some Office Hours questions. I’ve got a bunch of them, so let’s take a look.
The first one comes from Buy Low Sell High: “Times are tough with inflation, so shouldn’t TJX be performing well?” I’ll tell you this: I do think TJX is well positioned. When I’ve been into a TJX store, or one of its other stores like HomeGoods, over the last few weeks, they’ve been chock-full not only of holiday merchandise but also of people, and the lines have been long, not too different from what you see at Costco. So I suspect TJX will put up a good report and say some good things about the holiday shopping season, and we’re inclined to remain holders. Last I looked, it’s a 4% position in the Portfolio, which handcuffs us a little from adding more. But for folks looking for areas outside of tech, I think TJX is going to be a good one. I would, however, wait to hear the comments from the retailers starting tomorrow, and if they’re supportive, then make a move on TJX. We’ll be tracking all of that and talking with you about it.
Buy Low Sell High also asks: “Where do you see NVIDIA going from here? We’ve had a downward trajectory since October, though buyers stepped in after the news in the morning.” Again, this was a couple of days ago. Look, I think people are trying to figure out at what point the valuation is compelling, even if we haircut NVIDIA’s valuation given the uncertainty. Others, and I think Dan Ives said this on CNBC today, are saying there’s NVIDIA with Jensen and NVIDIA without Jensen. To some extent, you can argue the spotlight Jensen carries is now off the company. But if we look back at other companies that have undergone similar transitions, with the benefit of hindsight, they’ve tended to work out rather well. Everybody points to Apple, and in this case I think it’s a good example. I’ve mentioned it before, but I’ll reiterate: when Steve Jobs passed and Tim Cook came in, the roadmap was established for the next three to five years, much like what we know at NVIDIA. So I think the stock is going to be higher in the coming 12 months. Once all of this falls by the wayside, we’ll be focused on the fundamentals: tracking the AI and data center build-out data points and capital spending dollars, and hearing from companies like Foxconn, TSMC, Dell and the like. When that happens, I think the market will come back to NVIDIA, especially given its competitive position. That’s the way I’m looking at it.
The next question comes from AJIDM: “What are your thoughts on Anthropic’s IPO numbers? Do you think the proposed valuation is justified? Would you consider investing at the expected IPO price?” I can take that last one pretty easily, because we don’t partake in IPOs. We’ll take a first look after some of the lockup expirations start to happen. If you think about it, that’s what we did with SpaceX. We made a bit of an exception with SpaceX ahead of the big one that’s supposed to come in December. That was really because of the outlook for the SI business, or the former AI business, or the digital infrastructure business, call it what you will. You can really see that impact, especially once Anthropic’s proceeds start flowing through to SpaceX. I think that has the potential to flip the way people view profit generation at SpaceX, which heretofore has really been about the Starlink business, and bring some rethinking on SpaceX. That’s why we made the move, and I think the Anthropic IPO will be a good catalyst for it.
As far as pricing, I have to say I think the way it’s being handled is pretty good. Remember, several months ago the talk was $2 trillion, way up here, then $1.5 trillion, and then articles and chatter saying it should be much lower. What the bankers did was let demand build for the book and then start to ratchet it up. Last we heard, sometime late last week, the book was looking six times oversubscribed. That tells me the price talk of 70 to 78 should, at a minimum, be very firm, and I wouldn’t be surprised if it goes a little higher. That’s really the way you want to price an offering like that: let the market dictate the price and build enthusiasm for the offering. Ultimately, we’ll see where it gets priced. Do I think it’ll go above the range? Probably. Could they upsize the deal? Possible. But again, we don’t play IPOs.
I’ll also be following it carefully to see what it means for the IPO window, which, as you know, is really important for our positions in Morgan Stanley and Bank of America. At the same time, M&A activity and other financings have been stronger than people expected back in early October.
The next question comes from SBVA: “Any recommendations on getting into the Anthropic IPO? Would the club consider a small position, or even putting it in the Bullpen or EPS All-Stars?” I think we just covered the first part. As for EPS All-Stars, that really comes down to what the EPS numbers are when we recast that strategy in December. As for putting it in the Bullpen, never say never. But right now we’re particularly tech-heavy, and I think we’d have to rejigger some of what we have in it if we were to add any more AI, data center or digital infrastructure names.
The next question comes from Second Opinion: “It might be early to ask this, but is it possible to send the EPS All-Stars selling alert on December 30 instead of December 31? December 31 will be a short day of trading, and for those of us who work and don’t see the trades, that would be nice.” Look, we’re always happy to work with people. We realize there are certain days with shortened windows, and that can be a little challenging, so we’ll certainly factor that into our thinking. Steve, thank you for flagging that.
Buy Low Sell High: “Is it too late to get into Google? It’s rated a Two, but it’s pulled back here.” Google is one of those positions we’re taking a look at. I think we have a little room, not a tremendous amount, but let’s let the market find its footing. I do think what Google is doing on search, and in continuing to monetize not only advertising but YouTube, is very important. I also see them picking up share on the Google Cloud side. So yes, I’m interested in picking up a little more Google at the right price, and I think we’ll have more to say on that before too long.
Another one from Buy Low Sell High, from a couple of days ago: “Given the current economy, gas prices and inflation, why is gold at a 52-week low? Is this the bottom, and how does it impact our portfolios and the broader economy?” I don’t have a good answer for you on gold, but I do think there are a couple of things at work here. The economic data so far remains favorable, and gas prices, believe it or not, have been coming down. As I’m saying this today, they’re around $3.80-ish according to AAA, but I saw $3.50 and $3.60 over the weekend. I think that’s important to keep in mind from a psychological perspective. I recognize there are other drivers of inflation out there, but a lot of what we’ve been hearing about is higher transportation costs. That’s more diesel, but even diesel is starting to come down. So, again, I just don’t have a good answer for you on gold.
Next is from PJ Smuckers: “Now that we have a government shift, do you plan to lighten up on the chip and AI trade and rotate into some lower-beta, blue-chip dividend payers?” As I said earlier, if you look at some of the movements in the Bullpen, we’re certainly going that way. I mentioned Toast, IFF and a couple of others in the Bullpen. We’re also interested in bringing XLV back in and having a more well-rounded Portfolio over time. Do I think we’ll get there immediately? I don’t. Part of that is because the chip stocks and others related to AI and the data center have been a little volatile on the one hand. On the other hand, they’re at very depressed levels relative to their growth prospects. I think at some point we’ll see a realignment of that, and we’ll continue to evaluate over time.
And there’s one last question: “Chris, if SpaceX is going to buy Tesla, why would the Portfolio buy SpaceX?” Interesting question, because typically you want to buy the company being bought, not the buyer, and I think that’s where the rationale for the question comes from. A couple of things. First, we did write a piece last week saying there may be an announcement as soon as December. But the reality is that any deal like this is going to take a long time and be very complex. There are questions about Tesla’s China business, and there will be regulatory approvals on several fronts, especially given some of the business SpaceX is involved in. So do I think this will be a quick deal? I do not.
That means at some point people will focus on the things I talked about a few minutes ago at SpaceX: the continued growth in Starlink, and the revenue ramp and push into profitability for SI. And even today, as I talked about this morning, there’s SpaceX successfully completing that mission over the weekend, compared with what we saw with Boeing and Lockheed Martin. That’s going to, A, prompt some deep investigations into what happened; B, continue to weigh on reputational risk at Boeing; and C, create a bottleneck there. I think that positions SpaceX favorably as a result. So we’re comfortable with it. We’ll continue to chip away at the SpaceX position, but we’ll be mindful of what the Tesla announcement and the eventual pairing mean. Again, I think that’s going to be a long road.
So that, my friends, is today’s Office Hours. Again, I know you’re frustrated and some folks want some action, but let’s be prudent, be careful, be mindful of the technicals and take each day one at a time. I’ll be with you all day, every day, not just the coming week but going forward as well. If you have questions or comments, put them down below or in the forum, and we’ll be collecting questions later in the week for our next episode of Office Hours. Thanks for watching.
More Pro Portfolio:
- We’re Adding to Our Robotics Holding
- Tracking Over 45 Portfolio Signals That Speak to Our Investment Strategies
- Weekly Roundup: Jensen Huang’s Exit Rattles AI as We Trade Boeing for SpaceX
At the time of publication, TheStreet Pro Portfolio was long GOOGL, NVDA, and TJX.
