Narratives are Nice, But Extreme Sentiment is Investable
Investors love to find narratives, but the fact is that it’s the data that produces the best investments. So, here’s what the data is currently saying about the stock market.
You've reached your free article limit
You've read 0 of 1 free Pro articles.

Most market players like when markets are not extreme. Most people prefer when things are steady. As a contrarian, I like extremes. I like it when it feels like too many are on one side of the boat.
At the NAAIM Conference in late October, I presented that chart of the Sentiment Cycle coupled with Nasdaq. It had not broken yet. I mostly got yawns when I showed it. But one person asked (there is always one!) what the news would be that would take Nasdaq down like that. My response, which is probably always my response, was, if I knew it would already be priced in.
Did any of us have any clue that Jensen would be embroiled in a scandal that would lead to his departure from the company? I know that was definitely not on my bingo card. Out of the dozen things I could have answered that man with, this would have not been on the list. As I have said before, I am terrible at narratives.
With that in mind, I ask you, if I had told you two months ago that NVIDIA would go from 240 to 150 in almost a straight line, where would you have guessed the S&P would be? I suspect most would have said something like ‘easily 7000’. Yet the S&P still finds itself at 7300. So you see, it’s very hard, especially for me, to give you the why, especially before it occurs.
What I can tell you is that if we can get the market to head down in the next few days (so let’s say up Thursday but then down again), we might get a few extremes. For example, the Overbought/Oversold Oscillator has plunged. The math says it should tick up Thursday, but then come back down, but by midweek next week it ought to finally get back to an oversold condition (recall last week I said it would be overbought this week).


What I can tell you is that the put/call ratio’s ten-day moving average is now at .97. It has been a slow grind upward, but if we can get a few more days of high readings, this should finally equal the July reading. Not an extreme, but good enough.

What I can tell you is that the DSI for the S&P is now at 15. As I explained yesterday, that now puts it in the yellow light zone. I always prefer a single-digit reading, which would make it extreme. Can this be enough? It can, but single digits is better.
Nasdaq is at 20, so I’d love that to be a teenager too.
However, the metals are all extreme now. Gold is at 10. Silver is at 9, Platinum is at 9, as is Palladium. Copper is still 15, though.
Stocks are on the edge of extreme. I don’t know if we can push them into extreme, but we are the closest we’ve been in a while. What will the narrative be?
