investing

Doug Kass: The Fall of FTX and Sam Bankman-Fried

Be like Larry (David) because fortune doesn't favor the brave or the gullible (Matt Damon).

Doug Kass·Nov 3, 2023, 2:30 PM EDT

You've reached your free article limit

You've read 0 of 1 free Pro articles.

Already registered or a Pro member? Log in

"History is filled with almosts. With those who almost adventured and almost achieved but ultimately for them it proved to much. Then there are others, the ones who embraced the moment and commit. In these moments of truth, these mere mortals, just like you and me. And, as they peer over the edge, they calm their minds and their nerves with four simple words that have whispered since the Romans... Fortune favors the brave."

-Matt Damon, FTX commercial

Thursday Sam Bankman-Fried, FTX's founder and chairman was convicted of seven counts of fraud and faces up to 100 years in prison.

Here is a good summary of the rise and fall of Elizabeth Holmes in cargo shorts (Sam Bankman-Fried) in a recent  60 Minutes episode.

As I summarized in a November 22, 2022 column in my Diary, investors, the beautiful people (e.g., Vogue's Editor in Chief Anna Wintour), government officials (Senator Mitch McConnell, President Biden, etc.), sports figures (Tom "My boy Sam" BradyAll 3 Tom Brady FTX commercial ' FTX Tom Brady and Gisele Bundchen - YouTube , Shaq, Steph Curry), actors (Larry David, Matt Damon) and the business media (CNBC, Et al.) were duped in the weirdest, but to some of us, the most obvious of frauds:

* Once again investors have been duped by "an empty wagon" - this one was named FTX and was "managed" by Sam Bankman-Fried

Most of the cheerleaders, above, were paid off and were terribly conflicted.

The business media cheered though the "warning signs" (some of which are discussed in this column) were abundant.

The most egregious and vivid example of poor reporting, cheerleading and the absence of healthy (and critical) skepticism in the interviewing process was seen in this gushing Kate Rooney interview on CNBC with Sam Bankman-Fried which occurred only four weeks before SBF's indictment.

But there were many others, especially in the business media that cheered SBF (and his celebrity) on.

The few critical and objective critics, like Keith McCullough and my old friend Mark Cohodes, were confined to Twitter (and other less conspicuous venues) and did not have a broader platform for distribution of their skeptical views in the business media:

https://www.twitter.com/Hedgeye/status/1591240664779743232

I continued with my criticism one year ago:

* There will be more revelations and more losses due to counter party failures and vanished cryptos in the endless tentacles of an interconnected crypto sphere.

* There were plenty of FTX enablers (many of whom were conflicted) - including strategists, commentators and members of the business media.

* Sam Bankman-Fried was neither the JP Morgan or the White Knight of Crypto - he was just another empty wagon and fraud.

Some were on to SBF's scam, but like my criticism, there was little coverage:

Keith McCullough on X: "How pathetic (and sad) is it that the Old Wall Media who got paid to pump #FTXscam and #SBF to The People... is the same media trying to get paid on their click-bait tonight as they are all found guilty? @AlderLaneEggs @EpsilonTheory @WilliamCohan @gmorgenson https://t.co/ppPuSMJ284" / X (twitter.com)



I continued a year ago:

* Larry David had the ticket, FTX wasn't a safe way to get into crypto - it wasn't like the invention of the wheel, the fork, the toilet, coffee, the right to vote, the light bulb, the dishwasher, putting a man on the Moon - it wasn't even portable music.

* It wasn't new, 'It stinks' - one of the worst ideas Larry ever heard... traders/investors should have "curbed their enthusiasm."

In this column I called out FTX/Fried's enablers and I hope that a lesson has been learned (Hint: Most will not!):





"Like I was saying its FTX, its a safe and easy way to get into crypto... Eh, I don't think so. And I am never wrong about this stuff. Never!"

Larry David, here.

"Bitcoin is evil and stupid.... Crypto is an investment in nothing and the guy who's trying to sell you an investment in nothing says, 'I have a special kind of nothing that's difficult to make more of. It is an open sere full of malicious organisms.'"

- Charlie Munger, Berkshire Hathaway, here.

"What we have learned from history is that we haven't learned from history."

- Benjamin Disraeli, former exchequer of England

"As my friend Jim Chanos likes to say, "Legal Fraud" happens in America... Until The People lose a LOT of money."







- Keith McCullough

FTX's epic failure has plumbed the deaths of human investing folly.

It is singularly the fastest destruction of such a large amount of capital ($32 billion) of all time:

View Chart »View in New Window »











FTX is Bernie Madoff, Theranos, Baldwin United, Enron, Worldcom, Tyco International, Bre-X Minerals, HealthSouth, ZZZZ Best, the dot.com stocks (that collapsed in the early 2000s), the Covid gewgaws (of 2020-21) and Cathie Wood's portfolio -- all wrapped into one big slice of "Group Stink":

View Chart »View in New Window »















Here is an example of some (FTX) "stuff" you can't make up:

View Chart »View in New Window »

I Blame Many... Especially The Business Media Who Blindly Paraded Sam Bankman-Fried to Celebrity Status

* Much like they have done with Theranos' Elizabeth Holmes and ARK Invest's Cathie Wood

Cryptocurrencies were confidently pushed by leading market strategists, commentators in the business media -- who, benefiting from the commercial relationship, delivered puff pieces and pitched softballs in interviews with Sam Bankman-Fried FTX still has $1 billion to deploy, says CEO Sam Bankman-Fried -- blindly paraded Sam Bankman-Fried to celebrity status and by high profile investors and private equity firms.

And crypto was pushed by the two pied pipers of crypto, Galaxy Investors' Michael Novogratz and Micro Strategy's Michael Saylor, both of whose previous business failures/blowups were well known but ignored.

FTX/crypto went mainstream and even engulfed the then "golden couple" of model Gisele Bunchen and NFL quarterback Tom Brady -- who took an equity stake in FTX last year and appeared in a prominent television commercial... who were investors in FTX.

As I have noted in my Diary and in Barron's, Matt Damon (during the Super Bowl) erroneously told us MATT DAMON ENDORSES CRYPTOCURRENCY that fortune favors the brave. Here is my early October column on the subject, "Beware of Celebrity Endorsements of Stocks and Other Asset Classes."

At least "Curb Your Enthusiasm's" Larry David had the ticket.

As noted above, arguably also contributing to the ridiculously inflated valuation of FTX, NFTs, other crypto dealers and phony cryptocurrencies, were the large amounts of money that went into the advertising coffers of leading business media platforms.

The amount of FTX's influencing peddling was extraordinary -- it had little bounds, ranging well beyond the media and into entertainment, sports and politics.

Here is an example of the influence peddling incorporated in outsized contributions to individuals seeking office from both parties:

View Chart »View in New Window »







Calling Out Sam Bankman-Fried's Enablers

There were numerous conflicts of interest by those that had been compensated directly or indirectly by FTX.

Not calling them out by name lets them off the hook -- as people's life savings have been lost.

I can't help not to name one particular individual -- because he is among the most self confident, who is never in doubt and often wrong -- he was one of the few ones who confidently and delightedly publicly disclosed his role as a spokesperson:

"In managing the decision of which projects to invest in - I am very fortunate my deal flow is amazing. I have to disclose I am a paid spokes person to FTX and a shareholder there, too. I am a big advocate for Sam because he has two parents that are compliance lawyers. If there is any place that I can be and not get into trouble its going to be FTX."

- Kevin O'Leary (Mr. "Not So" Wonderful)

Here is more:

"If there is ever a place I can be and I am not going to get in trouble, it is going to be at FTX"

Mr. Wonderful @KevinOlearyTV

- GuruLeaks (@Guruleaks1) November 11, 2022

But most of all, the FTX and the collapse in cryptocurrencies represented hubris, a loss of common sense, the absence of analysis -- in a financial world that, these days, seems to know everything about price and nothing about value -- and embracing of "group stink" by even some of the most sophisticated investors or our era (Paul Tudor Jones, Sequoia, Tiger Global, Third Point, Soft Bank, Lightspeed and Circle). Factbox: What are FTX's investors saying? - Reuters.

There were other signs. like this:

In the months leading up to its demise, FTX spent hundreds of millions of dollars on a marketing spree -- which included a 19 year sponsorship as they purchased the naming rights last year to The Miami Arena, home of the NBA's Miami Heat, another warning signpost:





Within that sign there were other indications:

View Chart »View in New Window »

Didn't investors see the signs when Celsius, Voyager Digital and venture fund Three Arrows Capital all failed months ago?

"Next time I come on I am going to wear a Sam Bankman-Fried tee shirt."

- The Mooch on CNBC

Wasn't the nonsensical (and synergy-lacking) purchase by FTX Ventures of 30% of A's SkyBridge Capital a sign?

"What people are missing is the closeness of our two firms... Sam as a person and the culture that he is setting for FTX and the long term vision... We put $40 million into bitcoin on our balance sheet. if you understand the 1907 crisis when JP Morgan stepped into the crisis. Sam is the JP Morgan of our day. He will be at the top of the crypto food chain."

- Anthony Scaramucci

Or El Salvador's embracing of bitcoin as a parallel currency.

More Lessons Learned

Unfortunately, as has been the case throughout financial history -- it is only a few outsiders that reveal the truth. Like Harry Markopolos who revealed the Madoff fraud and Jim Chanos who uncovered frauds in Baldwin United and Enron. And recently, Marc Cohodes, Mike Lewitt and Keith McCullough that saw right through Sam Bankman-Fried's BS.

Cryptocurrency regulation has been lacking and the absence of such regulation has likely led to the FTX fraud.

But, to me, the lesson to investors, is to perform better due diligence and to not foolishly jump on speculative band wagons without doing research and considering "the value you get" (source: Warren Buffett).

I have been an outspoken bear, even entitling one of my columns, I Call BS.

In light of FTX's bankruptcy I feel it is important for me to post my prior columns on the illusion of cryptocurrencies -- here is May 11th's "I Remain at Outspoken Bitcoin Bear".

Bottom Line







"Virtue sometimes pretends,. Vice is always sincere."

- Mason Cooley

FTX was a monumental failure -- a failure of accountability and transparency, filled with numerous supporters possessing clear but often unexposed conflicts of interests and driven by fraudulent actions -- "borrowing" customer funds and creating FTX coins and using/showing them as reserves, among other nonsensical and bogus moves.

With a good perspective on history, we can have a better understanding of the past and present and thus a clearer vision of the future.

Learn from history and, importantly, who you can trust as a resource in your trading and investing process.

Be independent of view and do your analysis.

Always be a skeptic.

Be Larry David.

Because (it) FTX stinks like fish from the head -- as Larry David reminded us in the television commercial.

Sam Bankman-Fried was not the next Warren Buffett, he was the next Bernie Madoff.

As Joe Frazier once said "An empty wagon makes the most noise."

Speaking of The Oracle of Omaha, I have long concurred with his partner Charlie Munger who described Bitcoin as stupid -- because it is very likely to go to zero -- evil -- as it undermines our currency system -- and made him look foolish compared to somebody else -- like the Communist leader in China who correctly banned Bitcoin. Here is a great video of Warren and Charlie discussing bitcoin at this year's Berkshire Annual Meeting.

P.S.: You may not make any money reading this column, but you will likely save a lot of money in the future -- if you pay heed to the signs and analysis!

(This commentary originally appeared on Real Money Pro on November 3. Click here to learn about this dynamic market information service for active traders and to receive Doug Kass's Daily Diary and columns from Paul Price, Bret Jensen and others.)

At the time of publication, Doug Kass had no position in the securities mentioned.