Buying Is Fun. Selling Makes You Money.
Every sell decision is a trade-off, and can be painful. Having a systematic approach, however, can help ensure success.
You've reached your free article limit
You've read 0 of 1 free Pro articles.

Almost everything you read about the stock market is about buying: Which stocks to buy, when to buy them, how to find them. No one wants to talk about selling. Even in the worst bear markets, the primary focus is on buying rather than selling.
It is understandable why this happens. Buying is the fun part of the investment process. Selling is the hard, unpleasant work, but it is what determines your profits and how much money you keep. When you focus on buying, you start fresh. There are no regrets or mistakes to worry about. When you are selling, you are forced to admit that you could have done better, because no sale is ever perfect.
The Pros Would Do Better Throwing Darts
If you think the professionals have this figured out, you have been misled. A study called “Selling Fast and Buying Slow,” by researchers from the University of Chicago, Carnegie Mellon and MIT, looked at millions of trades by professional money managers. The managers were good at buying. Their selling was so poor that they would have done better by simply selling stocks at random.
The reason is that they put all their effort into finding new buys and treated selling as an afterthought. They had no plan for it. When they needed cash, they tended to dump whatever had made the biggest move, up or down.
Why Selling Is So Hard
Part of the problem is that buy points are universal, but sell points are personal. A good entry is largely the same for a day trader and a long-term investor. Selling depends on your time frame, your style, your cost basis and your emotions. A good place for one trader to sell is a good place for another to buy.
The bigger problem is that every sell decision is a tradeoff. No exit gives you everything. When you book a gain, you sacrifice additional potential, and when you hold for the potential, you give up the certainty of the booked profit.
The Sure Thing or the Home Run
Selling comes down to one question. To what extent do you take the sure thing vs. holding longer and trying for the home run? And when you do hit that home run, when do you decide that the game is over? Many Nvidia (NVDA) holders have been struggling with these questions recently.
Most stocks are not home runs. A typical winner runs for a week or two and then gives some of it back. If you hold everything waiting for an even bigger move, you will watch a lot of nice gains shrink or disappear. So it pays to be systematic about taking gains, and to do it fairly aggressively.
But the home runs are what make the difference between OK results and spectacular results. A handful of big winners carry the year, and if you sell them too early, no amount of disciplined profit-taking will make up for it.
Kristjan Kullamägi is a former security guard who turned about $5,000 into an account worth more than $100 million in roughly a decade. He is one of the traders featured in Market Wizards: The Next Generation, the new book by Jack Schwager and George Coyle.
An analyst, James Muninn, went through more than 800 of Kullamägi’s breakout trades and compared two ways of selling. One was to sell part of the position into strength a few days after the breakout and hold the rest. The other was to hold the whole position until the stock broke its trend.
Making partial sales produced a smoother ride and more trades that finished with a profit. Holding everything, however, made more money per trade on average. The entire difference between the two approaches came from about 10 trades, the monster winners that kept running long after everyone else would have sold. Ten trades out of more than 800.
At the start of the trade, the home runs looked exactly like every other winner. You can’t tell early on whether you are holding an ordinary winner or the one that will make your year.
Do Both
Since you can’t know which is which, the solution is to sell in pieces. Take some of the sure thing on every winner. Sell part of the position into strength and lock in a gain. Then keep a core position and trail it, so that if the stock turns into a home run, you are still on board.
Even the best traders struggle with this. Kullamägi has talked about giving back a million dollars in a few weeks because his stops were too loose, and about selling a stock far too early and watching it keep running without him. His advice to people who can’t stand watching profits fade is simple: “Just sell some into strength.”
A rule you will follow beats a better rule that you abandon the first time it hurts. Selling in pieces is a rule most people can live with.
The Door Stays Open
There is a tactic I use that makes the trade-off much easier. A sale doesn’t have to be the end of the story.
When you trim a winning position into strength, plan to buy back the shares you sold when the stock pulls back and sets up again. That is the remount trade I wrote about last month. If the stock turns out to be a home run, you still own the core, and you have a plan to get bigger. If it isn’t, you locked in a gain and kept your capital working.
That changes the math. Selling a piece of a winner is no longer a bet that you know where it tops. It is a way to take the sure thing without giving up on the home run.
Make Selling the Priority
The reason that the professional managers in that study would have done better selling at random is that they didn’t have a plan. Don’t make the same mistake. Spend as much time on your exits as you do on your entries. Decide in advance how you will trim, where you will trail your stop and what will make you buy back.
Good buying produces good results. Good selling produces great results.
At the time of publication, DePorre was long NVDA.
